Who’s Been Hoodwinked?
This is Father Jared Cramer from St. John’s Episcopal Church in Grand Haven, Michigan, here with today’s edition of Christian Mythbusters, a regular segment I offer to counter some common misconceptions about the Christian faith.
A couple weeks ago I talked about demons and darkness. Last week I set this episode aside to talk about the election, but I want to pick that older thread back up now. A couple weeks ago I told you that a progressive church like mine still does believe in the forces of darkness, including demons, and in the importance of resisting them. I also talked about why Bible study, worship, and healthy community are so important to that resistance, especially because the forces of darkness and the corrupt systems of every age love to hoodwink the church, using religion for their own ends.
Now, I’m keenly aware that some Christians would say that is exactly what has happened to my own Episcopal Church. I hear what some in our community say about me, that I am a false teacher or even a servant of the devil, whether because of our advocacy for immigrants or LGBTQIA+ people or a host of other questions. They could have heard that segment and felt called to resist me.
And, of course, many of my own members might feel the same calling in reverse, knowing that many who oppose our church are also ardent supporters of Christian nationalism.
So who is to say who is right? Has my church been hoodwinked by the evil forces of this age by supporting gay, lesbian, queer, and trans people? Have other churches been hoodwinked by supporting Christian nationalism?
Where’s the myth, and how do we bust it?
I think the first step is an honest understanding of church history, because we can certainly find times when the church was hoodwinked by the forces of its day… and what that looked like. The earliest churches were remarkably egalitarian, with women serving as leaders, deacons, and even apostles. But by the late first and early second century, the patriarchal norms of the wider Greco-Roman world pushed that egalitarian vision aside in favor of a male-dominated structure.
Later, the church too often became an arm of empire, an agent of violence and oppression. In the decades before the Civil War, many American Christians, especially in the South, were confident that God and the Bible called them to defend slavery.
With the 20/20 hindsight of history, we can see clearly that those were all times the church got it wrong, uncritically adopting the perspectives of its time and corrupting its own witness.
But what about when you are in the midst of it? How do you know which side is corrupted and which is authentic?
Jesus actually gave us a test, and he gave it while warning about false prophets. In Matthew 7, he says, “You will know them by their fruits.” Not by how certain they sound, not by how many Bible verses they can quote, not by how loudly they claim to be on God’s side. By their fruits.
And Paul spells out those fruits in Galatians 5: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, generosity, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control. He contrasts them with things like enmity, strife, anger, and factions.
Jesus gave us another, even simpler, measure. He said all the law and the prophets hang on two commandments: love of God and love of neighbor. So, we must always ask what approach faithfully furthers that love.
What do we do? We look at the fruit. When the church sided with empire, with patriarchy, with slavery, the fruit was violence, exclusion, and the crushing of the vulnerable. When the church has been faithful, the fruit has looked like the life of Jesus: the outcast welcomed, the hungry fed, the stranger protected, the powerful humbled.
You can also look at the community itself. Does the community seem to be shaped by and produce love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, generosity, faithfulness and gentleness… self-control? Or does the community seem to produce enmity, strife, anger and factions? These fruits tell us whether something is of God… or not of God.
But here is the hard part, and it is where the myth really gets busted. That test is meant first for our own hearts, not as a weapon against someone else. I have to ask whether my life and my parish are bearing the fruit of love, and I have to keep asking that question.
Because, as Paul reminds us, our struggle is not against flesh and blood. Even those with whom we disagree most deeply are not our enemies. They are beloved children of God, and in the end it’s probably true that all of us are hoodwinked at some level, because none of us is infallible. So we always have to keep asking, keep prodding, and keep testing.
Because the moment any of us forgets that those on the other side are still beloved children of God, the forces of darkness have already started to win.
Thanks for being with me. To find out more about my parish, you can go to sjegh.com. Until next time, remember: protest like Jesus, love recklessly, and live your faith out in a community that accepts you but also challenges you to be better tomorrow than you are today.