What Looks Like Cost Creep Is Developing Your Best People
In the sixth video of his Dirty Little Call Center Secrets series, Kongusto founder Joel Ciniero explains a pricing trap he calls “planned churn,” and why it can push a call center to let go of its best agents.
Joel Ciniero says he has clients who moved their business to Kongusto for this reason alone. “It’s called planned churn,” he says, and he describes the setup as one where “the game is rigged going into it.”
It starts with how call center pricing works. A client asks for a quote and receives one all-in price per agent, which Ciniero says covers the agent’s salary, taxes, insurance, health care and vacation, plus a desk, a phone, a computer, power, coffee, toilet paper and a conference room. The core of that price, he explains, is the agent’s salary, set at the market rate for the skills required.
The first year tends to go well. Ciniero calls it “the honeymoon year.” The client has identified the best agents, the team includes what he calls rock stars, and the client’s own customers are noticing the difference. Then year one ends, and the agents hired a year earlier start to think what any professional would: they have grown in the job and expect a raise. A smart call center, he says, will run reviews, propose an increase to the client and pass the raises along, because someone who has worked for you for a year is worth more than someone who started yesterday.
The problem is that many clients expect call center service to be like a lease, with a price fixed for 24, 36 or 48 months. “That’s not real,” Ciniero says. As people do more and learn more, they become more valuable, and if the price is frozen, he asks, “what happens to the supply?” His answer is that it goes away. The call center ends up churning out its best people to protect the agreed price, even though losing them is costly. A brand-new agent carries more risk than one who has done a great job for a year, and the call center is squeezed by what Ciniero calls margin creep.
He argues that clients should look at rising costs differently. “What looks like wage inflation to you or call center cost creep is actually developing the best people,” he says, which in his view leads to happier customers and better results than a service where churn is built into the formula.
His warning to clients is plain. Pushing a call center to hold the price, he says, is the same as telling it to let go of its best people and keep bringing in cheaper replacements. “Don’t do that,” Ciniero says. It is bad for the client’s business, hard on the call center and likely to cost the client customers to a provider that “does it right.”
For telecom providers and other companies that outsource support, the point is worth raising when a contract is first discussed.
The takeaway: A price that never moves can force a call center to trade away its most experienced agents. Planning for fair raises is how clients keep the people who make the service good.
Watch Joel Ciniero’s Dirty Little Call Center Secrets video on planned churn.
Connect with Joel Ciniero
Joel Ciniero is President and Founder of Kongusto, a nearshore outsourcing company. To learn more about his perspectives on business leadership, workforce strategy, and outsourcing excellence, visit www.kongusto.co or contact him at joelc@kongusto.co.