Episodes

Jay Hunter is back to propagate a fascinating theory that the Egyptian Pyramids were actually CHEMICAL PLANTS. The idea comes from Geoffrey Drumm of The Land of Chem. Episode Links: Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

Thanks to Rigby Stunkleman, we choose to be HOPEFUL ABOUT THE FUTURE, even if it's dumbest thing we'll do all year. Episode Links: Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

Enter our TOP 5 MOVIES of 2025, with your cinema reviewers Nate Ballard, Joe Cabello and Sasha Feiler. Expect overlaps. Expect surprises. Episode Links: Thread Corner Honeymoon Improv Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

Actor David Rodgers and one of the hosts spar over whether Die Hard (1988) is a Christmas movie -- or simply one of the greatest movies ever made. Episode Links: Sasha's Writing Class Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

Here’s a FREE PREVIEW of our latest Check-In Episode, aka "Shut Up Sasha and Joe." To hear more, head to https://www.patreon.com/c/ShutUpILoveItPodcast Check-In Episode # 30: On fleek. 6-7. Not getting the whole eyebrows thing. Great hair, terrible personality.

Holiday spirit courtesy of Jay Hunter -- enter a rewatch of MANDY (2018), a hallucinatory nightmare directed by Panos Cosmatos, starring the one and only Nic Cage. Episode Links: Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

Here’s a FREE PREVIEW of our latest Check-In Episode, aka "Shut Up Sasha and Joe." To hear more, head to https://www.patreon.com/c/ShutUpILoveItPodcast Check-In Episode # 29: The Predator Badlands pin that got away. Five long hours at the Apple Store and the disillusion that comes with it.

Disgraced reporter and alleged criminal Damiana Garcia is back with one of the most disturbing episodes yet. Is it about LOUNGE SINGING -- or an idea that will haunt your nightmares? Only one way to find out. Episode Links: Michael Lucid's IG Michael Lucid's TikTok Sasha's Writing Class Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

Here’s a FREE PREVIEW of our latest Check-In Episode, aka "Shut Up Sasha and Joe." To hear more, head to https://www.patreon.com/c/ShutUpILoveItPodcast Check-In Episode # 28: Sasha once again boasts about her yoga mastery. Then we discuss some gruesome health issues.

Actor, writer and improviser Macklen Makhloghi takes us for a swim in the vast ocean that is the web series ON CINEMA AT THE CINEMA starring Tim Heidecker and Gregg Turkington. Episode Links: Macklen's IG Macklen's Twitter Thread Corner Honeymoon Improv Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

Here’s a FREE PREVIEW of our latest Check-In Episode, aka "Shut Up Sasha and Joe." To hear more, head to https://www.patreon.com/c/ShutUpILoveItPodcast Check-In Episode # 27: Joe's Murder Mystery dinner party. Sasha's first experience drawing a naked human body.

Jay Hunter, a famous cinematographer and director person, is also a domesticated man who loves HOME IMPROVEMENT (NOT the TV show). Episode Links: Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

Here’s a FREE PREVIEW of our latest Check-In Episode, aka "Shut Up Sasha and Joe." To hear more, head to https://www.patreon.com/c/ShutUpILoveItPodcast Check-In Episode # 26: Sasha and Joe explore the nature of love and friendship, suckling on one's aunt and get in a heated debate about an instagram video.

Actor and improviser David Danipour is here to love K-PAX -- not a Korean ab workout, but a 2001 film that lulls him to sleep within ten minutes, no matter the scene. In a good, soothing kind of way. Episode Links: David's Website David's IG David's YouTube Channel David's X Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

Actor, voice over artist and production extraordinaire Alyssa Appleton is here to share how BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER gave her a voice when she needed it most. Episode Links: Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website Alyssa's IG

What exactly are LEGACY SEQUELS, and why would anyone love them? Filmmaker and comedy writer Wahab Shayek is here to explain -- using LIVE FREE OR DIE HARD (2007) as his prime example. Wahab wrote Playmates, a short heist comedy that was selected to screen at the Tasveer Film Festival. He is also a proud (self-proclaimed) Cabello Bro 4 Life. Episode Links: Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

In this final SHUT UP I SCARE IT episode, actress Tessie Herrasti recalls the time when an EVIL ENTITY latched onto her trapezoid. Episode Links: Tessie's Website Tessie's IG Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

Actor, writer and improviser Macklen Makhloghi wants us to SHUT UP AND SCARE about the wonderfully surface-level Stephen King film SILVER BULLET (1985) -- a movie where nothing really pays off, but no one cares that it doesn’t. Episode Links: Macklen's IG Macklen's Twitter Thread Corner Honeymoon Improv Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

Here’s a FREE PREVIEW of our latest Check-In Episode, aka "Shut Up Sasha and Joe." To hear more, head to https://www.patreon.com/c/ShutUpILoveItPodcast Check-In Episode # 25: Killing things in your script. He was a Gilmore boy all along. Believing a cartoon when a turtle crawls out of its shell.

Producer and comedy man Gil Baron is back ​for a SHUT UP ​I SCARE ​e​episode about THE REAL GHOSTBUSTERS, the animated spin-off of the 1984 classic film that he calls “a perfect intro to horror.” Nostalgia for it has even struck people who grew up in Siberia. Episode Links: Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

Actor and comedian Shane Hartline (Obi-Wan Kenobi, Station 19) is back for our very first SHUT UP I SCARE IT! Shane’s heart forever belongs to Sam, the pumpkin-headed trick-or-treater from the spooky cult favorite T​RICK'R TREAT (2007). Episode Links: Shane's TikTok Shane's IG Shane's X Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

Here’s a FREE PREVIEW of our latest Check-In Episode, aka "Shut Up Sasha and Joe." To hear more, head to https://www.patreon.com/c/ShutUpILoveItPodcast Check-In Episode # 24: Alien: Earth. The inner workings of the podcast. Covid and throwing up.

Welcome to our first ever SHUT UP I REWATCH IT! Writer and Army veteran Rachael B joins us to revisit MOONLIGHTING, the hit ’80s TV series starring the feuding Bruce Willis and Cybill Shepherd. Note: this show is *NOT* BOSOM BUDDIES. Episode Links: Rachael's IG Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

Here’s a FREE PREVIEW of our latest Check-In Episode, aka "Shut Up Sasha and Joe." To hear more, head to https://www.patreon.com/c/ShutUpILoveItPodcast Check-In Episode # 23: In this episode Sasha talks about the superhuman powers that being a parent can give you. A little backstory: During the LA fires, Joe was near the Eton fire, Sasha was right by the Kenneth fire, and we were checking in on everyone -- each other, our friends, anyone who crossed our minds. This is when we remembered someth...